湖泊碳库效应及校正方法

doi:10.7522/j.issn.1000-694X.2014.00025

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 湖泊作为过去环境变化的信息载体，可以很好地提供高分辨率的连续记录，因此常被用来进行定年研究。湖泊沉积物放射性碳定年由于缺乏陆源植物残体、碳屑等可靠的定年材料，多选用其他材料（如全样有机质、水生残体及各类壳体），但是这些材料通常受到“碳库效应”（The reservoir effect）的影响，而使得年代结果失真，导致难以建立高精度的年代框架，成为这一领域研究放射性碳年代应用的瓶颈。因此，如何对湖相沉积物¹⁴C年代结果进行有效的碳库效应校正，对高精度年代序列的建立具有重要意义。本文综览了近几十年来针对湖泊碳库效应进行研究所取得的一系列研究成果，详细总结了影响湖泊碳库效应的各种因素，讨论了碳库效应对湖泊沉积物定年结果的影响；分析了目前对湖泊碳库的各类校正方法，包括使用同一测年手段、不同测年材料建立点上碳库大小以及采用不同测年手段对碳库的校正等。本文为湖泊沉积物高精度年代序列的建立提供了一定的参考。

关键词: 放射性碳测年, 湖泊碳库, 校正

Abstract: As lake sediment records can provide potentially high-resolution, continuous terrestrial archives of environmental changes, they play an important role in the reconstruction of past climate and environment conditions. Therefore, reliable chronologies are crucial to paleoclimatic studies. Among all dating methods, radiocarbon dating is one of the most useful tools for providing a chronological framework for paleoenvironmental study of lake sediment records. Radiocarbon dating on lake sediments is well known to be very complicated. Accurate chronologies cannot be easily obtained by radiocarbon dating because lack of terrestrial plant macrofossils and suitable dating materials, such as the terrigenous plant residues and charcoal. In fact, the chronology is often established using the organic matter, aquatic debris and various types of shells. However, the reservoir effect that having great influence on the radiocarbon dates with these materials has long been recognized. A closer look at the radiocarbon ages using bulk organic matter and other no-terrestrial macrorests reveals a systematic deviation of the ages on terrestrial plant residue and charcoals. This error has important implications for the resolution of precise event chronologies. In this paper, we review the knowledge from many researches about the reservoir effect in the lake sediment recent years, and detailed summarized the various factors that influenced the radiocarbon dating, discussed how they impact the dating results. We also analysis the current correction method for various types of the reservoir effect in the lake sediments, including the use of same radiocarbon dating method on different dating materials on a given site to find the accurate reservoir effect, and to use various dating methods on the same carbon materials, such as the radiocarbon dating, OSL methods, the ²¹⁰Pb/¹³⁷Cs dating and the U-series dating to measure carbon stocks in the correction and find out the high-precision chronology. We hope our work can give reference for future studies in this area.

Key words: radiocarbon dating, reservoir effect, age calibration

中图分类号:

K928.43

王宗礼, 何建华, 陈亚东. 湖泊碳库效应及校正方法[J]. 中国沙漠, 2014, 34(3): 683-688.

Wang Zongli, He Jianhua, Chen Yadong. The Reservoir Effect of Radiocarbon Dating in Lake Sediment System[J]. JOURNAL OF DESERT RESEARCH, 2014, 34(3): 683-688.

参考文献

[1] Currie L A.The remarkable metrological history of radiocarbon dating[J].Journal of Research of the National Institute of Standards and Technology,2004,109:185-217.
[2] Hajdas I,Lowe D J,Newnham R M,et al.Timing of the late-glacial climate reversal in the southern hemisphere using high-resolution radiocarbon chronology for Kaipo bog,New Zealand[J].Quaternary Research,2006,65(2):340-345.
[3] Harkness D D,Walton A.Further investigations of transfer of bomb ¹⁴C to man[J].Nature,1972,240(5379):302-303.
[4] Levin I,Kromer B.The tropospheric ¹⁴CO₂ level in mid-latitudes of the northern hemisphere (1959-2003)[J].Radiocarbon,2004,46(3):1261-72.
[5] 李育,周雪花,李卓仑,等.潴野泽沉积物有机地球化学指标与花粉组合的关系及其对环境变化的响应[J].中国沙漠,2013,33(1):87-93.
[6] 薛积彬,钟巍,赵引娟,等.东疆北部全新世气候不稳定性的湖泊沉积记录[J].中国沙漠,2008,28(4):648-656.
[7] 刘宇航,夏敦胜,金明,等.阿拉善地区湖泊岩芯磁性特征记录的全新世环境变化[J].中国沙漠,2012,32(4):929-937.
[8] Christine H,Luiz C P,Andreas L,et al.Development of accurate and reliable ¹⁴C chronologies for loess deposits:application to the loess sequence of nussloch (Rhine valley,Germany)[J].Radiocarbon,2001,43(2B):611-618.
[9] Olaaon I U.Radiocarbon dating history:early days,questions,and problems met[J].Radiocarbon,2009,51:1-43.
[10] Deevey E S,Gross M S,Huntchinson G E,et al.The natural ¹⁴C contents of materials from hard-water lakes[J].Proceeding of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America,1954,40:285-288.
[11] Geyh M A,Merkt J,Muller H.Sediment,Pollen,and Isotopenanalysen an jahreszeitlich geschichteten Ablagerungen im zentralen Teil des Schleinsees[J].Archiv Hydrobiologie,1971,69:366-399.
[12] Geyh M A,Schoeeerer U,Grosjean M.Temporal changes of the ¹⁴C reservoir effect in lakes[J].Radiocarbon,1998,40:921-932.
[13] Geyh M A,Grosjean M,Nunez L,et al.Radiocarbon reservoir effect and the timing of the Late-Glacial/Early Holocene Humid Phase in the Atacama Desert (Northern Chile)[J].Quaternary Research,1999,52:143-153.
[14] Benson L.Factors affecting ¹⁴C ages of lacustrine carbonates:Timing and duration of the last highstand lake in the Lahontan basin[J].Quaternary Research,1993,39:163-174.
[15] Olsson I U.¹⁴C dates and the reservoir effect[C]//van der Plicht J.Proceedings International Workshop on Isotope-geochemical Research in the Baltic Region,Lohusalu,Estonia,March 14-16 1996,Centre for Isotope Research,Groningen,the Netherlands,1999:5-23.
[16] Bartllett H H.Radiocarbon datability of peat,marl,caliche,and archaeological materials[J].Science,1951,114(2951):55-56.
[17] Stein M,Lazar B,Goldstein S L.Radiocarbon reservoir ages as freshwater-brine monitors in lake Lisan,dead sea system[J].Radiocarbon,2013,55(2/3):1050-1057.
[18] Fernandes R,Dreves A,Nadeau M J,et al.A freshwater lake saga:carbon routing within the aquatic food web of lake Schwerin[J].Radiocarbon,2013,55(2/3):1102-1103.
[19] Keaveney E M,Reimer P J.Understanding the variability in freshwater radiocarbon reservoir offsets:a cautionary tale[J].Journal of Archaeological Science,2012,39:1306-1316.
[20] Ascough P L,Church M J,Cook G T,et al.Radiocarbon reservoir effects in human bone collagen from northern Iceland[J].Journal of Archaeological Science,2012,39(7):2261-2271.
[21] Alix G C,Jan H,William E A.Marin radiocarbon reservoir ages in Scottish coastal and Fjordic waters[J].Radiocarbon,2006,48(1):33-43.
[22] Olsson I U.Accuracy and precision in sediment chronology[J].Hydrobiologia,1991,214:25-34.
[23] Hakansson S.Radiocarbon activity in submerged plants from various south Swedish lakes[C]//Berger R,Suess H E.Radiocarbon Dating.Proceedings of the Ninth International Conference.Los Angeles and La Jolla,USA:University of California Press,1979:433-443.
[24] Bondevik S,Mangerud J,Hilary H,et al.Changes in North Atlantic radiocarbon reservoir ages during the Allerd and Younger Dryas[J].Science,2006,312:1514-1517.
[25] Hendy C H,Hall B L.The radiocarbon reservoir effect in proglacial lakes:examples from antarctica[J].Earth and Planetary Science Letters,2006,241:413-421.
[26] Moreton S G,Rosqvist G C,Davies S J,et al.Radicarbon reservoir ages from freshwater lakes,South Georgia,sub-Antarctic:modern analogues from particulate organic matter and surface sediments[J].Radiocarbon,2004,46(2):621-626.
[27] Zoppi U,Albani A,Ammerman A J,et al.Oreliminary estimate of the reservoir age in the Lagoon of Venice[J].Radiocarbon,2001,43(2A):489-494.
[28] Olsson I U.The varying radiocarbon activity of some recent submerged estonian plants grown in the early 1990s[J].Radiocarbon,2010,43(2B):809-820.
[29] Brook G A,Cherkinsky A,Railsback L B,et al.~+~{14~}C dating of organic residue and carbonate from stromatolites in Etosha pan,Namibia:¹⁴C reservoir effect,correction of published ages,and evidence of >8-m-deep lake during the late Pleistocene[J].Radiocarbon,2013,55(2/3):1156-1163.
[30] 吴艳宏,王苏民,侯新花.青藏高原中部错鄂全新世湖泊沉积物年代学研究[J].中国科学(D辑),2006,36(8):713-722.
[31] 吴艳宏,王苏民,周力平,等.岱海¹⁴C测年的现代碳库效应研究[J].第四纪研究,2007,27(4):507-510.
[32] Fontes J C,Gasse F,Gibert E.Hollocene environmental changes in Lake Bangong basin (West Tibet),Part 1:chronology and stable isotope of carbonates of a Holocene lacustrine core[J].Palaeogeography,Palaeoclimatology,Palaeoecology,1996,120:25-47.
[33] Shen J,Liu X,Wang S et al.Palaeoclimatic changes in the Qinghai Lake area during the last 18000 years[J].Quaternary International,2005,136:131-140.
[34] Watanabe T,Matsunaka T,Nakamura T,et al.Last glacial-Holocene geochronology of sediment cores from a high-altitude Tibetan lake based on AMS ¹⁴C dating of plant fossils:Implications for paleoenvironmental reconstructions[J].Chemical Geology,2010,277:21-29.
[35] Hua Q.Radiocarbon:a chronological tool for the recent past[J].Quaternary Geochronology,2009,(4):378-390.
[36] Suiver M,Braziunas T F.Sun,ocean,climate and atmospheric ¹⁴CO₂:an evaluation of causal and spectral relationships[J].The Holocene,1993,34:289-305.
[37] Hutchinson I,James T S,Reimer PJ,et al.Marine and limnic radiocarbon reservoir corrections for studies of late- and postglacial environments in Georgia Basin and Puget Lowland,British Columbia,Canada and Washington,USA[J].Quaternary Research,2004,61:193-203.
[38] 沈吉.湖泊沉积研究的历史进展与展望[J].湖泊科学,2009,21(3):307-313.
[39] Feng Z D,Wang W G,Guo L L,et al.Lacustrine and eolian records of Holocene climate changes in the Mongolian Plateau:preliminary results[J].Quaternary International,2005,136:25-32.
[40] 郑同明,赵家驹,安成邦,等.巴里坤湖孢粉浓缩物¹⁴C测年可行性研究[J].海洋地质与第四纪地质,2010,30(1):83-86.
[41] 孙千里,肖举乐.岱海沉积记录的季风/干旱过渡区全新世适宜期特征[J].第四纪研究,2006,26(5):781-790.
[42] Xiao J L,Xu Q H,Nakamura T,et al.Holocene vegetation variation in the Daihai Lake region of north-central China:a direct indication of the Asian monsoon climatic history[J].Quaternary Science Reviews,2004,23:1669-1679.
[43] Grimm E C,Maher L G,Nelson D M.The magnitude of error in conventional bulk-sediment radiocarbon dates from central North America[J].Quaternary Research,2009,72:301-308.
[44] Zhang J F,Liu C L,Wu X H,et al.Optically stimulated luminescence and radiocarbon dating of sediments from Lop Nur (Lop Nor),China[J].Quaternary Geochronology,2012,10:150-155.
[45] Long H, Lai Z P,Wang N A,et al.A combined luminescence and radiocarbon dating study of Holocene lacustrine sediments from arid northern China[J].Quaternary Geochronology,2011,6(1):1-9.
[46] Srdoc D,Horvatincic N,Obelic B,et al.The effects of contamination of calcareous sediments on their radiocarbon ages[J].Radiocarbon,1986,28(2A):510-514.
[47] Bard E,Arnold M,Fairbanks R G,et al.²³⁰Th-²³⁴U and ¹⁴C ages obtained by mass spectrometry on corals[J].Radiocarbon,35(1):191-199.
[48] Hall B L,Henderson G M.Use of uranium-thorium dating to determine past ¹⁴C reservoir effects in lakes:examples from Antarctica[J].Earth and Planetary Science Letters,2001,193:565-577.
[49] Borg K,Stein M,Jong AFM,et al.Near-Zero Δ¹⁴C Values at 32 Kyr Cal BP observed in the high-resolution 14C Record From U-Th Dated Sediment of lake Lisan[J].Radiocarbon,2004,46(2):785-795.