风沙跃移解析模型的建模思路及存在问题

doi:10.7522/j.issn.1000-694X.2024.00006

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

以Bagnold模型、S?rensen模型和P?htz-Kok-Herrmann模型（PKH模型）为样本，分析了跃移通量解析模型的发展趋势、建模思路及存在问题。与Bagnold模型不同，Owen类模型的建模包括风廓线方程与颗粒群运动学特征方程的参数化求解等环节。S?rensen模型以反映气固耦合过程的跃移轨迹方程的参数化求解为主要的建模策略。PKH模型分别以气流动量传递方程、能量传递方程及风廓线方程的参数化求解为建模策略，在表观粗糙度、粒载切应力垂直衰减廓线及冲击起动的定量表达等方面取得了重要的进展。改进跃移观测的准确度、进一步理解跃移通量变化的峰值现象、充分考虑多尺度湍流对跃移通量的影响等，是发展解析模型的潜在途径。

关键词: 跃移通量, 风沙颗粒, 建模思路, 表观粗糙度, 粒载切应力

Abstract:

Several saltation models including Bagnold model， S?rensen model， and P?htz-Kok-Herrmann （PKH） model have been summarized by analyzing the development trend， model ideas， and problems. In contrast with Bagnold model， the Owen Type of saltation models just like S?rensen model and PKH model involve the parameterized solutions of wind profile equations over aeolian saltation layer and the parameterized motions of saltating particles. The S?rensen model is based on the parametric solution of the leapfrog trajectory equations reflecting the gas-solid coupling process as the main modeling strategy. More specifically and deeply， PKH model parameterizes the force and work rate balances； and the solution of wind profile equations； accordingly， providing new insights into apparent roughness， grain shear stress profile and impact threshold. The analytical saltation models can be improved by more accurate observations， reevaluation of saltation flux peaks， and parameterization of the effect of multi-scale wind on saltation flux.

Key words: saltation flux, aeolian saltating particle, model ideas, apparent roughness, airborne stress profile

中图分类号:

P931.3

梅凡民, 杨倩文, 李旺, 苏进. 风沙跃移解析模型的建模思路及存在问题[J]. 中国沙漠, 2024, 44(4): 14-23.

Fanmin Mei, Qianwen Yang, Wang Li, Jin Su. An overview of analytical models of saltation[J]. Journal of Desert Research, 2024, 44(4): 14-23.

图/表 1

参考文献 53

1	Bagnold R A.The Physics of Blown Sand and Desert Dunes［M］.London，UK：Methuen，1954：265-270．
2	Shi Z， Krom M D， Bonneville S.Atmospheric processing outside clouds increases soluble iron in mineral dust［J］.Environmental Science & Technology，2015，49（3）：1472-1477.
3	Kok J F， Storelvmo T， Karydis V A，et al.Mineral dust aerosol impacts on global climate and climate change［J］.Nature Reviews Earth & Environment，2023，4（2）：71-86.
4	Kawamura R.Study on sand movement by wind［J］.Report，1951，5（3）：95-112.
5	Zingg A W.Wind tunnel studies of the movement of sedimentary material［C］//Proc.5th Hydraulics Conf.，IAHR.1952：111-135.
6	Owen P R.Saltation of uniform grains in air［J］.Journal of Fluid Mechanics，1964，20（2）：225-242.
7	Kadib A L A.A Function for Dand Movement by Wind［M］. Berkeley，USA：University of California，Berkeley，1965.
8	Lettau K.Experimental and micrometeorological field studies of dune migration［J］.Exploring in the World's Driest Climate，1978：110-147.
9	White B R.Soil transport by winds on Mars ［J］.Journal of Geophysical Research Solid Earth，1979，84（B9）：4643-4651.
10	Dong Z， Liu X， Wang H，et al.Aeolian sand transport：a wind tunnel model［J］.Sedimentary Geology，2003，161（1/2）：71-83.
11	Sørensen M.On the rate of aeolian sand transport［J］.Geomorphology，2004，59（1/4）：53-62.
12	Creyssels M， Dupont P， El Moctar A O，et al.Saltating particles in a turbulent boundary layer：experiment and theory［J］.Journal of Fluid Mechanics，2009，625：47-74.
13	Durán O， Claudin P， Andreotti B.On aeolian transport：grain-scale interactions，dynamical mechanisms and scaling laws［J］.Aeolian Research，2011，3（3）：243-270.
14	Ho T D， Valance A， Dupont P，et al.Scaling laws in aeolian sand transport［J］.Physical Review Letters，2011，106（9）：265-270.
15	Pähtz T， Kok J F， Herrmann H J.The apparent roughness of a sand surface blown by wind from an analytical model of saltation［J］.New Journal of Physics，2012，14（4）：43035-43077.
16	Martin R L， Kok J F.Wind-invariant saltation heights imply linear scaling of aeolian saltation flux with shear stress［J］.Science Advances，2017，3（6）：e1602569.
17	Zhang Y， Li M， Wang Y，et al.Reinvestigation of the scaling law of the windblown sand launch velocity with a wind tunnel experiment［J］.Journal of Arid Land，2019，11：664-673.
18	Kok J F， Renno N O.A comprehensive numerical model of steady state saltation （COMSALT）［J］.Journal of Geophysical Research：Atmospheres，2009，114（D17）：011702.
19	Dupont S， Bergametti G， Marticorena B，et al.Modeling saltation intermittency［J］.Journal of Geophysical Research：Atmospheres，2013，118（13）：7109-7128.
20	Li Z， Wang Y， Zhang Y.A numerical study of particle motion and two-phase interaction in aeolian sand transport using a coupled large eddy simulation-discrete element method［J］.Sedimentology，2014，61（2）：319-332.
21	Wang P， Feng S J， Zheng X J，et al.The scale characteristics and formation mechanism of aeolian sand streamers based on large eddy simulation［J］.Journal of Geophysical Research：Atmospheres，2019，124（21）：11372-11388.
22	Huang N， He P， Zhang J.Large-eddy simulation of sand transport under unsteady wind［J］.Geomorphology，2020，358：107105.
23	Zheng X， Jin T， Wang P.The influence of surface stress fluctuation on saltation sand transport around threshold［J］.Journal of Geophysical Research：Earth Surface，2020，125（5）：005246.
24	Kamath S， Shao Y， Parteli E J R.Scaling laws in Aeolian sand transport under low sand availability［J］.Geophysical Research Letters，2022，49（11）：097767.
25	Leenders J K， Van Boxel J H， Sterk G.Wind forces and related saltation transport［J］.Geomorphology，2005，71（3/4）：357-372.
26	Baas A C W.Wavelet power spectra of aeolian sand transport by boundary layer turbulence［J］.Geophysical Research Letters，2006，33（5）：5403-1-5403-4.
27	Baas A C W.Complex systems in aeolian geomorphology［J］.Geomorphology，2007，91（3/4）：311-331.
28	Davidson-Arnott R G D， Bauer B O.Aeolian sediment transport on a beach：thresholds，intermittency，and high frequency variability［J］.Geomorphology，2009，105（1/2）：117-126.
29	Ellis J T， Sherman D J， Farrell E J，et al.Temporal and spatial variability of aeolian sand transport：implications for field measurements［J］.Aeolian Research，2012，3（4）：379-387.
30	Li B， McKenna Neuman C.Boundary-layer turbulence characteristics during aeolian saltation［J］.Geophysical Research Letters，2012，39（11）：L11402-1-L11402-4.
31	Chapman C， Walker I J， Hesp P A，et al.Reynolds stress and sand transport over a foredune［J］.Earth Surface Processes and Landforms，2013，38（14）：1735-1747.
32	Shi F， Huang N.Measurement and simulation of sand saltation movement under fluctuating wind in a natural field environment［J］.Physica A：Statistical Mechanics and Its Applications，2012，391（3）：474-484.
33	Bauer B O， Davidson-Arnott R G D.Aeolian particle flux profiles and transport unsteadiness［J］.Journal of Geophysical Research：Earth Surface，2014，119（7）：1542-1563.
34	Li B， Neuman C M K.A wind tunnel study of aeolian sediment transport response to unsteady winds［J］.Geomorphology，2014，214：261-269.
35	Li X， Wang G， Zheng X.Turbulent/Synoptic separation and coherent structures in the atmospheric surface layer for a range of surface roughness［J］.Boundary-Layer Meteorology，2022，182（1）：75-93.
36	Zheng X J， Bo T L.Representation model of wind velocity fluctuations and saltation transport in aeolian sand flow［J］.Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics，2022，220：104846.
37	Tan L， Wang H， An Z，et al.Aeolian sand transport over a dry playa surface：Sand flux density profiles，saltation layer height，and flux scaling laws and implications for dust emission dynamics［J］.Catena，2023，224：106970.
38	Frangi J P， Richard D C.The WELSONS experiment：overview and presentation of first results on the surface atmospheric boundary-layer in semiarid Spain［J］.Annales Geophysicae，2000，18：365-384.
39	Gerety K M.Problems with determination of u* from wind-velocity profiles measured in experiments with saltation［C］//Proceedings of International Workshop on the Physics of Blown Sand.1985：271-300.
40	Butterfield G R.Near-bed mass flux profiles in aeolian sand transport：high-resolution measurements in a wind tunnel［J］.Earth Surface Processes and Landforms，1999，24（5）：393-412.
41	Li Z S， Ni J R， Mendoza C.An analytic expression for wind-velocity profile within the saltation layer［J］.Geomorphology，2004，60（3/4）：359-369.
42	Zhang W， Kang J H， Lee S J.Tracking of saltating sand trajectories over a flat surface embedded in an atmospheric boundary layer［J］.Geomorphology，2007，86（3/4）：320-331.
43	Walter B， Horender S， Voegeli C，et al.Experimental assessment of Owen's second hypothesis on surface shear stress induced by a fluid during sediment saltation［J］.Geophysical Research Letters，2014，41（17）：6298-6305.
44	Sherman D J， Li B.Predicting aeolian sand transport rates：a reevaluation of models［J］.Aeolian Research，2012，3（4）：371-378.
45	梅凡民，江姗姗，王涛.粗糙床面风廓线的转折特征及其物理意义［J］.中国沙漠，2010，30（2）：217-227.
46	梅凡民，张宁宁，席媛，等.粗糙床面风廓线统一对数区的空气动力学粗糙度及其空间变异特征［J］.中国沙漠，2018，38（3）：445-454.
47	Dong Z， Sun H， Zhao A.WITSEG sampler：a segmented sand sampler for wind tunnel test［J］.Journal of Desert Research，2003，59（1/4）：119-129.
48	Dong Z， Qian G， Luo W，et al.Analysis of the mass flux profiles of an aeolian saltating cloud［J］.Journal of Geophysical Research：Atmospheres，2006，111（D16）：006030.
49	Kang L， Guo L， Liu D.Reconstructing the vertical distribution of the aeolian saltation mass flux based on the probability distribution of lift-off velocity［J］.Geomorphology，2008，96（1/2）：1-15.
50	Kang L， Zou X， Zhao G，et al.Wind tunnel investigation of horizontal and vertical sand fluxes of ascending and descending sand particles in aeolian sand transport［J］.Earth Surface Processes and Landforms，2016，41（12）：1647-1657.
51	Dong Z， Huang N， Liu X.Simulation of the probability of midair interparticle collisions in an aeolian saltating cloud［J］.Journal of Geophysical Research：Atmospheres，2005，110（D24）：006070.
52	Huang N， Zhang Y， D'Adamo R.A model of the trajectories and midair collision probabilities of sand particles in a steady state saltation cloud［J］.Journal of Geophysical Research：Atmospheres，2007，112（D8）：007480.
53	Carneiro M V， Araújo N A M， Pähtz T，et al.Midair collisions enhance saltation［J］.Physical Review Letters，2013，111（5）：058001.